This is not to say he is bullish on the dollar but that he is not in the death blow camp because of the problems the other big currencies have. Japan has bigger problems, a lot of debt and a bigger demographic problem, and the euro has problems galore as well.
As opposed to trying to sort out whether he is correct or not it might make more sense to sort out what to do assuming he is correct and I would add that if his thesis is correct it will play out very slowly giving time for recognition and implementation.
I am likely to have Chinese equity exposure more often than not for a long time to come. Plenty has occurred there already but there is still plenty more. The country is going to move up the chain and life in the ground there is going to improve substantially but of course there will be cyclicality, the occasional policy mistake and other growing pains but China is one spot where it is happening. That said, I doubt my exposure will ever exceed 6-7% of the portfolio.
If we do get to a point where the world is trying to sort out between the USD, JPY, EUR, CNY or some basket dominated by those four I think I would rather sidestep that (mostly) and favor currencies, and by extension equities from those countries, that can grow and thrive irrespective of the world reserve issue.This line of thinking leads me to quite a few familiar (to long time readers) countries but it makes sense to expect the list to evolve over time. In no particular order Canada, Australia, Norway, Chile, Israel, New Zealand (at some point), Brazil, Vietnam and Singapore (if there were ever to be a pan Asian currency it would be based on SGD and it is not clear to me if that would be a good thing or not).
In the future there would probably be some additions from Africa (Egypt has an interesting story but is difficult to access), Kazakhstan (resources galore and corruption galore), some of the Arabic countries pegged to the USD will probably have to break the peg at some point due to inflation threats and maybe some place like Peru should be part of the conversation. Feel free to add others as you think of them.
These types of countries, regardless of which ones really should be thought of in this context the idea is to gravitate to smaller, hopefully simpler countries that are either in their own world, can sell things that the big dogs have to buy or some combo of the two.
As has been a common refrain around here this would require more work not less but if the hegemony debate really devolves into who is the least unhealthy wouldn't you want to seek out the healthier countries anyway?
The picture is from in the hoodoos at Bryce on the Navajo Loop.










11 comments:
One thing about China is that they are ALWAYS interesting to watch. THey've almost GOTTA have huge reserves because they're gonna have to import so much in the future.
It seems like each argument in favor of China ruling the world has a counter-argument that some kind of resource issue, whether it be water, arable land, food in general, oil, enviromental issues, etc.
Roger:
Off-topic, but I just read an article on commodity etf's badly lagging the indexes. I had previously read things like this in regard to single commodity etf's (like oil and nat gas) badly lagging due to contango or backwardization - don't remember which.
So I just read mthat the goldman sachs commodity index is up around 48%, and noted that the etf GSG is up only 15% - don't know if there have been distributions.
OUCH!!
Any comments or opinions on this for those that want some commodity type allocation??
Prescott Wayne
Nice post but I noticed that one prominent country is missing in your list.
Is there any particular reason for not including India ?
The iShares page for GSG has different numbers than what you posted. I don't follow the fund so I don't know which numbers are correct but assuming your numbers are correct I see that the fund is 70% in energy, which is why I don't follow the fund, which makes me think it would look a lot like USO in terms of having contango issues. Just a guess.
For most clients India will happen (or not) without them...for now anyway.
Wondering why you see New Zealand in the top 6. Running into people from New Zealand vacationing I have heard a number of times that the younger generation needs to go to Australia to find work. Makes me think the country is maintaining and not growing much.
oy, a lot of 1+1=11 there.
Despite my saying in no particular order and at some point about NZ....
the country sells a lot of dairy products to china and will sell more as time goes on.
Roger, OT topic, but thought you may have an insight to provide. I recently purchased STPZ. There is a monthly distribution for the etf. This month there was no distribution. I queried PIMCO and was informed that the distributions were based on a trailing two month basis, so the distribution for September was actually an inflation adjustment for July, where there was nothing to distribute. My question to PIMCO after finding this out (this was not disclosed in the prospectus, which I read pretty thoroughly) was whether the etf would become a vehicle for arbitrage, since the income would be well defined ahead of time. The reply was no, this would become reflected in the base value. My question for you, is this a concern if inflation heats up and a distribution becomes 1-2% , or a cause for the reverse situation, a flurry of short positions to capture a reversal. It will not effect my holding the etf, just provide me with knowledge to understand volatility.
Thanks, Sam
I do not know if people would try to game that and I am not sure what exactly someone would be gaming (I think I understand your question). My general understanding is that as an indexed fixed income product they trade very efficiently under "normal circumstances" WRT to this sort of thing. Every so often all hell breaks loose like it did last fall and it would be reasonable to think that every so often someone very smart, or with the right software, could scalp something.
That is just my hunch on the topic however I would take no confidence in what a phone rep said to you about it unless they got flooded with that same question and someone higher up told the frontline folks what to say.
Smart Move: Foreign Currency Investments
I got a few questions about what foreign currencies are good investments right now. Because there is so much interest in this matter, I thought it'd be great to discuss it here.
Now, the most important thing to remember is that investing in a foreign currency must never be considered in isolation. Consider its impact on your entire portfolio. For example, let’s say you have $20,000 in U.S. investments and you read an article that is very positive on Brazil so you go and invest $5000 in Brazil. You now have 20% of your overall investments only in Brazil which is a lot, even if you do have most of your investments in domestic currency. Ask yourself if you want to be so exposed to a single country.
A currency will do well versus the dollar for two reasons:
(1) The American economy is not doing well, so the dollar weakens. This is true at the moment.
(2) The foreign economy is doing well, so the foreign currency strengthens.
All non-dollar currencies share the first reason to some extent, so focus on the second reason. Look for currencies of countries that have low government debt, growing economies, younger population, stable politics, well-run or reforming legal systems and robust capital markets. China, Korea and India exhibit these signs. Countries that produce commodities like oil, copper etc. are also attractive as the world comes out of recession. Australia, Canada and Brazil are examples.
Again, all investing decisions must be made after considering the entirety of your financial situation.
For more visit my homepage at http://www.themoneyladder.com
"smart money advice for smart young people"
I want to second the comment for India.
I also think india has a better chance of displacing the US for reserve currency. India has its problems, but it is a DEMOCRACY with a proven judicial system as oppossed to a communist china that could change its mind on a whim and devalue its currency and confiscate your assets.
It will take numerous decades for India to displace the US, but I think it is a better bet than Euro, china, Japan, and all other possibilities.
That said I am still keeping my China investments as well.
Any comments or opinions on this for those that want some commodity type allocation??
Prescott,
I own the PIMCO Commodity Real Return Fund (PCRDX) for my commodity allocation. It has done a more effective job of tracking the underlying commodity index compared to the ETFs:
http://stockcharts.com/charts/performance/perf.html?PCRDX,$CRB,GSG
Post a Comment