Wikinvest Wire

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Wednesday Morning Twofer

I have never been in the housing market is going to crash camp and still am not. I do think this business with Bear Stearns and any other stories like it has the potential to be disruptive and further impact capital markets.

To the extent that markets are interconnected, something unusual in some big segment, like the mortgage market, can cause problems for asset prices without causing people to lose their houses or causing home values to cut in half as some fear.

However the the bond market is very complex, the equilibrium between various bond market segments is complex, disruptions to that equilibrium will cause visible reactions. I am not calling for Armageddon, the the thought that this increased stock market volatility will persist seems very plausible.

Something at sometime will cause the next real correction, I suppose this could be it but I am not sure yet. For now the increased volatility for stocks looks more like a stalling out than anything else, if it deteriorates more so be it but whatever happens I can't imagine it will be unprecedented.

The following quote is from the Chinese Restaurant episode of Seinfeld;

GEORGE: Excuse me, I'm expecting a call. Costanza?

BRUCE: Yeah, I just got a call. I yell 'Cartwright! Cartwright!' Put Write! Put Write!, just like that. Nobody came up, I hang up.

GEORGE: Well, was it for Costanza or...

BRUCE: Yes, yes, that's it. Nobody answere


The CBOE has created a new product called the CBOE Put Write Index and can be quoted on Yahoo Finance with ticker ^PUT.

The idea behind the index is to sell cash secured at-the-money SPX puts that expire in one month.

This chart comes from the CBOE PDF that explains the index. Cash secured put selling is a fairly conservative strategy for people who know what they are doing and understand leverage.

I will say that I am amazed that it had periods of outperformance when the market was declining.

Also interesting is that according to page four of the PDF PUT has a lower standard deviation than the Buy Write Index (BXM) and a version of the S&P 500 they refer to as S&P 500 Total Return.

Another article you can read on this is from Index Universe, which is where I first found ^PUT. I doubt CBOE brought this out as merely an academic exercise. I suspect we will see an exchange traded something that mimics it soon.

A common theme to my writing has been that investment products will evolve in such a way that do-it-yourselfers who are able to spend the time will be able build very sophisticated portfolios for themselves.

The idea of having 1/3 of your equity portfolio in eight or nine products that take different routes to reliable 7-8% returns with a lot less volatility that the stock market makes sense for investors who have saved properly and really understand the concept of risk adjusted returns.

6 comments:

Mr. Happy said...

Roger - all of mortgage stuff reminds me of one of your favorite books FIASCO. Adding to it the rush of the S&P to downgrade previously AAa bonds at GS and my mind wonders to the derivatives market.... It’s obviously the doomsday market of choice to point to, but I'm afraid I'm starting to point with the crazy old men in the corners! EVERYTIME the market has been unregulated there has been a scandal. If we had let LTC and or Mexico actually smash, we may have regulations to protect us.... Now I'm blabbering. Love the posts.

Douglas said...

Roger-I don't think housing will crash but it won't keep up the pace of the last several years, we've already seen drops in prices in certain areas. My concern is if the consumer is no longer able to take $$ out of his house (Home Equity has been out of control) won't that have a very negative effect on the economy. The average Joe and the government have a negative savings rate. At some point this will catch up.

Roger Nusbaum said...

FIASCO was a great read.

Douglas, I agree it has the potential to be problematic just not Armageddon-matic.

Anonymous said...

Shouldn't the CBOE Put Write Index have the same performance as the BXM?

Whats causing the discrepancy, Treasury yields going down?

Anonymous said...

Roger,

I'm writing in response to your article on SeekingAlpha.com about BuyWrite funds. If you check with the CBOE, there are two studies done by different consulting firms that analyze statistics of the BXM and the effect of adding BXM to a larger portfolio. The Sharpe ratios are quite impressive. The Callan study goes all the way back to 1988.

I would email them to you if I had your email but I'm sure you can find them on the CBOE website.

T said...

Likely, i have worn out my welcome here in regards to real estate. But I shall try agin to make a point.

The only FIASCO in the sub-prime mess is missing a golden opportunity to purchase income producing real estate on the cheap, with superb returns relative to the vagaries of many security investments.

It is predictable for bond fund kings and talking heads to milk the sub-prime situation for their own benefit (buy good, safe bond funds and pad my commission/watch my panic driven show so I get better ratings).

Foreclosures are up, credit busts are up, housing starts are pretty dismal - so don't buy the stocks or bonds of the institutions that created their own mess. Buy the physical property that is on fire sale and rent it. There is a growing number of both commercial and personal renters - dramatically so, since many have managed their finances poorly and can only afford to rent.

The tax bonanza of property ownership is not on any political chopping block for a good reason.
Landlords will just raise the rents and/or increase their write-off ratio to offset any incursion into their business.

IMO, individuals that do not have actively managed real estate (you determine your own tolerance-it should be more than zero) in their portfolio are neither diversified or correctly investing in the right area of real estate - the property itself.

Proud Member Of